Many Forms of Violence against Women

The feminist approach to violence against women for the past three decades has generally emphasized the common experience of all abused women in order to strengthen the feminist movement to eliminate violence in the lives of women. However, this approach has often been criticized as ignoring the experiences and voices of marginalized women, including immigrant and refugee women, disabled, aboriginal, poor, and lesbian women. The assumption that domestic violence affects every woman across race, class, ethnicity, nationality and religious sphere equally, has been nothing less than tokenism and an attempt at including diversity.

Over the years, tremendous effort was put into developing a victim’s feeling of sisterhood; tag lines such as ‘domestic violence affects everyone equally’ became the mantra. Risks assessment tools developed to meet the needs of Caucasian women from host societies were used to assess and manage the needs of the newly arrived immigrant women, resulting in flawed risk assessment and flawed safety plans. This became evident when Canadians were shocked to learn that four women, who were found in a car submerged in a canal in Kingston, Ontario, had on numerous occasions sought help from school counselors, neighbours, police, Children’s Aid and other front line service providers before they were killed. The three teenagers knew their life was in danger, they just did not have the life experience and the vocabulary to explain the eminent danger they were facing.

The severity or the prevalence of violence in women’s lives cannot adequately be measured without taking into account the facts that different cultures define violence differently. For example, in the South Asian community, which is most familiar to me, domestic violence is not the same as intimate partner violence or honour based violence. In all three terminologies, the perpetrators and victims are different than those generally understood by mainstream service providers. Moreover, while violence against women is a global phenomenon, the manifestation of violence against women is rooted in cultural traditions and practices. It is undeniable that violence against women is grounded in patriarchal control but these patriarchal controls manifest differently based on culturally rooted expectations and practices which are often transported to Canada by many immigrant communities.

The traditional feminist perspective argues that violence against women is a consequence of socially constructed gender inequality. I agree, but this view ignores the woman’s race, class, ethnicity, immigration experience, marital status, economic, and education, which often results in real life consequences for immigrant women seeking safety. For example, it is important to recognize that the violence and control by the patriarch of the family is not the only form of abuse experienced by immigrant women; there are many cases in which both victim and perpetrator are women, where a mother might abuse, injure or kill her daughter in the name of family honour.

The impact of culture on individual behaviour has been discussed, debated and explored for decades, but many academics and scholars in the area of violence against women have overlooked the role that culture has in perpetuating violence against women. Sensitive to the feelings of the new Canadian, they have struggled with examining cultural practices which are harmful to women in an attempt to prevent stigmatization and discrimination. As a result, there is very little literature on how to train clinicians, social workers, police officers and other frontline service providers to be effective in various cultural contexts.

In my workshop on ‘Honour Based Violence’ culture is defined as:

“An integrated pattern of behaviour shared among a group of people that includes ideology, thoughts, beliefs, speech, action, which is passed from one generation to the next through ceremonies, rituals and traditions.”[1]

Given this definition, the main role of culture is to give a group of people guidelines for living and interpreting their lived experience. Culture provides a guideline for how the world should be organized, the family constructed, the unique role of each family member and how the family and the community should be governed. If we avoid considering culture in risk assessment, we commit a serious error in assuming that everyone is ‘the same,’ and all violence against women is the same.

The risk assessment tools, counselling methodologies and other resources which were developed for the women from the dominant culture do not always serve the needs of many new Canadians from culturally diverse backgrounds.

[1] Nobles, (1986)

Related Post